why is hershey stock down

A data-driven explanation of why is hershey stock down: rising cocoa and input costs, volume weakness, margin pressure, earnings/guidance misses, analyst downgrades and macro headwinds — plus poten...

2025-09-26 03:19:00

By Emma Shah

Article rating

4.5

106 ratings

Bitget offers a variety of ways to buy or sell popular cryptocurrencies. Buy now!

A welcome pack worth 6200 USDT for new users! Sign up now!

Why is Hershey stock down?

The question "why is hershey stock down" has become common among investors and retail traders seeking to understand recent weakness in The Hershey Company (HSY). In this article we explain, with dated reporting and measurable indicators, the main drivers behind the decline in Hershey shares, the company responses, differing analyst views, potential recovery catalysts, and ongoing risks. Reading this guide will help you separate near-term headline drivers from longer-term fundamentals when evaluating HSY.

As of Aug 1, 2024, per Reuters reporting, Hershey trimmed its annual forecast after a quarter that showed profit pressure — a key turning point that triggered outsized market reaction. Later analyst downgrades and continued commodity volatility reinforced the decline. Throughout this article the phrase "why is hershey stock down" is examined across reported events and financial indicators to give a clear, neutral picture of the drivers behind the move.

Read time: ~12–15 minutes. Use the section links below to jump to what matters to you (company background, drivers, financials, catalysts, timeline, references).

Company background

The Hershey Company is one of the largest global confectionery and snacking firms. Its primary business lines include chocolate and confectionery brands, savory and snack offerings, and a growing array of packaged treats. North America accounts for the majority of Hershey's consolidated revenue and operating profit, making the company relatively sensitive to U.S. consumer trends.

Hershey's business model combines strong brand equity, a dense retail distribution footprint, and seasonality tied to holidays. This profile historically made HSY a defensive, consumer-staples name, but the post-2023–2025 period tested that characterization because of surging input costs and demand shifts.

Recent stock performance and market reaction

Investors seeking "why is hershey stock down" will find a sequence of price moves tied to specific news items and data releases:

As of Jan 12, 2024, Yahoo Finance reported HSY was down more than 20% in the prior six months, highlighting an extended pullback. This earlier weakness was linked to margin pressure and commodity cost concerns.
On Aug 1, 2024, Reuters reported that Hershey trimmed its annual forecast after quarterly results — an immediate trigger for a sharp drop in the stock price on that day.
Around Sep 26, 2024, multiple analyst downgrades were reported (Investopedia noted coverage of downgrades), reinforcing selling pressure and lower target prices.
In early 2025, Seeking Alpha and other analysts debated whether the share weakness presented a buying opportunity or a sign of structural demand problems. A Feb 4, 2025 Seeking Alpha piece framed the move as a contested risk/reward scenario.
By mid‑2025, long-form analysis (The Motley Fool, May 18, 2025) scrutinized the persistent share underperformance and the plausibility of sustained margin recovery timelines.

Market participants responded to these datapoints by reducing exposure, which in turn led to lower valuations such as contracting price-to-earnings multiples and expanded yield-to-risk for yield-seeking investors.

Primary factors behind the decline

When answering "why is hershey stock down", the key drivers fall into categories: rising input costs (notably cocoa), weakening consumer demand and volumes, pricing trade-offs, earnings misses and guidance cuts, higher operating/integration costs, analyst downgrades and sentiment, macro and currency headwinds, and discrete supply shocks.

Rising commodity/input costs (cocoa, sugar, freight)

One of the clearest, repeatedly cited reasons for the question "why is hershey stock down" is commodity-cost pressure. Cocoa, the primary raw material for chocolate, experienced significant price spikes due to production issues in West Africa, weather disruptions and disease impacting yields.

As of Aug 1, 2024, Reuters reported that rising cocoa costs materially increased Hershey's cost of goods sold (COGS), pressuring gross margins and leading management to trim guidance.
The price of cocoa and related freight/supply-chain premiums forced confectioners like Hershey to either absorb costs or pass them to consumers. Hershey chose a mix of price increases and operational mitigation, but the timing and magnitude of cocoa inflation outpaced immediate margin relief.

Higher input costs are measurable in reported gross-margin contraction in quarterly filings and were a leading proximate cause investors cited when asking "why is hershey stock down".

Weakening consumer demand and volume declines

Another recurring answer to "why is hershey stock down" is volume weakness. Several quarterly reports and analyst notes documented declines in unit sales or softening consumption frequency for confectionery items.

Consumers faced with elevated food inflation have been more price-sensitive, trading down to cheaper brands or reducing discretionary treats. This dynamic showed up as volume declines in key categories.
Management commentary in earnings calls (referenced in Reuters and Investopedia coverage) pointed to lower-than-expected retail velocity and an elongated trade-promotion environment, both of which weigh on reported sales growth.

Volume declines amplify the impact of input-cost inflation because price increases to preserve margins can reduce demand further, creating a negative feedback loop.

Pricing actions and trade-offs

Hershey implemented price increases to offset rising COGS. While necessary to defend margins, pricing creates trade-offs:

Passing costs to consumers helped limit margin deterioration, but at the expense of near-term sales growth and promotional intensity.
Price elasticity in certain confectionery segments meant that some consumers bought less frequently or shifted pack sizes — outcomes that contributed to observed volume declines and are part of the answer to "why is hershey stock down".

Earnings misses, downgraded guidance and financial results

Earnings execution and guidance changes were central to the sell-off. For many investors the clearest tangible evidence for "why is hershey stock down" was a sequence of quarterly misses and downward revisions:

As of Aug 1, 2024, Reuters reported Hershey trimmed its annual forecast after results fell short on profit metrics. That guidance cut was a materially negative signal to markets.
Subsequent quarters included instances where top-line growth or EPS lagged expectations, prompting analyst model adjustments and target-price reductions (Investopedia coverage in Sep 2024 noted such downgrades).

Earnings misses directly affect forward earnings multiples and institutional positioning, amplifying downward pressure on the stock.

Higher operating and integration costs

Beyond commodities, Hershey faced elevated SG&A and integration costs tied to growth initiatives and acquisitions. Increased investment in marketing, technology, and innovation — while potentially value-creating over the long term — added near‑term expense pressure.

Analysts attributed part of the margin compression that answers "why is hershey stock down" to these operating-cost trends, particularly when combined with lower-than-expected revenue progress.

Analyst downgrades and negative sentiment

Market psychology played a role. After key misses and guidance trims, analysts cut ratings and lowered price targets, which further pressured the stock.

Investopedia (Sep 26, 2024) highlighted a wave of analyst downgrades that followed disappointing results.
Media and commentary (including CNBC segments and MarketBeat headline aggregation) amplified negative sentiment and encouraged selling by momentum-sensitive funds.

Analyst downgrades translate into reduced demand from model-driven funds and can set off cascade effects in investor flows.

Macro and currency headwinds

Broader economic factors also help explain "why is hershey stock down":

Consumer discretionary softness during periods of high inflation reduces purchase frequency of non-essential snacks.
Higher interest rates compress equity valuations generally and make defensive dividend plays like Hershey less attractive relative to competing yield alternatives.
Currency headwinds affected international revenue translation, modestly reducing reported top-line growth in non‑USD markets.

These macro factors are less company-specific but magnified the impact of company-level problems.

Event-driven supply shocks (disease, weather)

Discrete events such as cocoa-tree diseases (e.g., black pod disease), adverse weather in key West African growing regions, and logistics disruptions raised concerns about future cocoa supply and pricing. These supply-shock narratives were repeatedly cited in coverage asking "why is hershey stock down", because they suggested a persistent input-cost problem rather than a short one-off blip.

Financial indicators and valuation metrics

Investors looking for quantitative backing to the question "why is hershey stock down" focused on several measurable indicators:

Sales trends: sequential and year-over-year top-line growth rates — several quarters showed decelerating revenue growth compared with historical baselines.
Gross margin: contraction in gross margin was a direct reflection of higher COGS and inadequate offsetting price or cost-savings.
EPS: earnings-per-share misses and downward revisions to forward EPS were prominent in analyst notes.
Free cash flow: while Hershey retained strong cash-generation history, short-term FCF was pressured by working capital and integration spend, relevant to dividend sustainability assessments.
Dividend yield and payout ratio: with share-price declines, yield rose mechanically, but investors scrutinized payout coverage amid margin pressure.
Valuation multiples (P/E, EV/EBITDA): multiples compressed as analysts lowered forward EPS and investors discounted risk, a central reason many asked "why is hershey stock down".

Many of these metrics were discussed in the coverage from Reuters, Investopedia and Seeking Alpha cited earlier; their cumulative effect explains the valuation reset.

Company responses and management actions

Hershey's management publicly addressed the issues driving the stock weakness. Key actions included:

Pricing strategy: targeted price increases and pack-size adjustments intended to recover margin without excessively harming demand.
Cost mitigation: productivity initiatives, SKU rationalization and supply-chain optimization aimed at lowering COGS and SG&A over time.
Portfolio and innovation: investment in new product formats, snacking adjacencies, and marketing to boost relevance and frequency.
Guidance transparency: revising forward guidance when necessary and increasing investor communication on cost actions and expected timing for margin recovery.

As of Aug 1, 2024, per Reuters, management’s forecast trim acknowledged that margin recovery would take longer than previously expected — a candid admission that influenced the market response and helps explain "why is hershey stock down".

Analyst and investor viewpoints

Views diverged across market participants answering "why is hershey stock down":

Bear case: persistent input-cost inflation, durable shifts in consumer purchase behavior, and ongoing margin pressure that could reduce long-term free cash flow.
Bull case: iconic brands, pricing power over the medium term, strong cash generation and dividend history make the decline a potential opportunity, especially if cocoa prices normalize.

Seeking Alpha (Feb 4, 2025) and The Motley Fool (May 18, 2025) presented deeper debate on whether HSY is a falling knife or an attractively valued consumer-staples opportunity — disagreements hinge on assumptions about commodity normalization and demand elasticity.

Potential catalysts for recovery

Investors looking for triggers that could answer the question "why is hershey stock down" in reverse (i.e., why it could recover) should track the following catalysts:

Easing cocoa supply constraints and lower cocoa prices, which would materially improve gross margins.
Clear signs of volume stabilization or re-acceleration in key categories.
Better-than-expected quarterly results or upgraded guidance from management.
Successful execution of cost-savings and productivity initiatives reducing SG&A and integration drag.
Positive analyst revisions and rating upgrades that restore investor confidence.

Each catalyst would need to be reflected in measurable financials (gross margin improvements, sales growth, EPS beat) to change investor positioning meaningfully.

Ongoing risks and uncertainties

Key persistent risks that continue to explain "why is hershey stock down" include:

Elevated or reemerging commodity price risk, especially cocoa.
Sustained consumer demand weakness or further trade-down behavior.
Integration setbacks or higher-than-expected SG&A investment that delays margin recovery.
Currency volatility and macroeconomic deterioration that reduces discretionary spend.
Market multiple compression if macro risk leads investors to de-risk equities broadly.

These uncertainties justify continued caution among many market participants until evidence of durable recovery appears.

Investment considerations (neutral, non-advisory)

This section is informational and not investment advice. When assessing HSY given the question "why is hershey stock down", consider:

Time horizon: Short-term traders may focus on catalysts and momentum; long-term investors should weigh brand durability and cash-flow potential.
Income profile: Hershey’s dividend and payout history can be attractive, but dividend safety depends on near‑term margins and cash flow.
Commodity sensitivity: Evaluate scenarios for cocoa/sugar price normalization and their impact on gross margins.
Valuation: Compare forward P/E and EV/EBITDA under conservative and optimistic EPS scenarios.

For traders and investors interested in executing trades or exploring custody options, Bitget offers trading services and a wallet for digital asset needs. Note: HSY is a U.S. equity; investors should use regulated stock brokers or platforms supporting U.S. equities for direct share ownership, and carefully consider platform features and compliance.

Timeline of notable events (select highlights)

Jan 12, 2024 — As of this date, Yahoo Finance reported HSY had fallen more than 20% over the prior six months, indicating earlier pressure on the stock.
Aug 1, 2024 — As of Aug 1, 2024, Reuters reported Hershey trimmed its annual forecast after a profit/margin‑pressured quarter; markets reacted negatively.
Sep 26, 2024 — As of Sep 26, 2024, Investopedia and related outlets covered analyst downgrades following continued earnings and guidance disappointment.
Feb 4, 2025 — Seeking Alpha published an analysis weighing whether Hershey was a buying opportunity or a falling knife, highlighting the debate over demand trends and cost trajectories.
May 18, 2025 — The Motley Fool ran a longer-form piece discussing persistent underperformance and scenarios where recovery could be delayed.
LevelFields case study (date varied) documented an event-driven decline near -28% tied to a cluster of negative news items and an earnings/guidance miss; this exemplifies the magnitude of the sell-off during peak concern.

References

The following sources were used to synthesize reporting and analysis for this article. Specific dates are included to preserve time context as requested:

Reuters, "Hershey trims annual forecasts...", Aug 1, 2024 (reporting on guidance trim and market reaction). Source used for management guidance and market impact.
Yahoo Finance, "Hershey (HSY) Down More Than 20% in 6 Months", Jan 12, 2024 (documented earlier multi-month decline).
Investopedia, "Analysts Downgrade Hershey Stock...", Sep 26, 2024 (coverage of analyst downgrades and model changes).
Seeking Alpha, "Hershey: A Falling Knife Or An Opportunity?", Feb 4, 2025 (debate-style analysis of risk/reward).
The Motley Fool, "Why Hershey's Bitter Stock Performance Could Become...", May 18, 2025 (long-form analysis of underperformance and potential outcomes).
LevelFields case study, "Hershey's Loses -28%..." (event-driven analysis documenting a steep intraperiod decline).
CNBC / Jim Cramer coverage (various video and article commentary cited for market sentiment and headline discussion).
MarketBeat, HSY headline aggregation and analyst-expectation tracking (used for summarizing the flow of headlines and analyst actions).

All the above reporting informed the neutral summary of drivers for the central question: "why is hershey stock down".

Notes on data and scope

This article focuses strictly on HSY as an equity and the corporate/market developments that affected its share price. It does not address unrelated uses of the name "Hershey".
Where on-chain metrics are standard for digital-asset coverage, they do not apply to HSY. Public equity metrics referenced here come from company reports and mainstream financial reporting.
Statements that reference sources include reporting dates to preserve context (e.g., "As of Aug 1, 2024, per Reuters").